Wendy helps around her house while her brothers, John and Michael, pretend they are pirates that are fighting for their ship.

Winnie begins to pack her things as she heads off to college. Her brothers Jake and Matt help her as she prepares this new beginning in her life.

Peter Pan travels through the town in search of his shadow, when he finds it in Wendy and the boy's bedroom, where she helps his sew it back on.

When she gets to school, she meets a boy named Patrick who shows her the way to her class.

Peter Pan decides to take them all to Never Land. He gives them some of Tinker Bell's pixie dust and tells them that it will only work with faith and trust.

Patrick decides to take her to a new diner down the street so they can have lunch and get to know each other.

Meanwhile in Never Land, Captain Hook and his partner Mr. Smee continue to run the Jolly Roger.

In the meantime, Patrick's ex-girlfriend, Hannah, and her best friend ,Sophia, are busy trying to figure out a way to get back at Patrick for breaking up with her.

Peter Pan takes the kids to their home, and introduces them to the lost boys.

Back at school, Patrick introduces Winnie to some of his friends that every one calls the lake boys, because they are always out at the lake at every chance they get.

The lost boys take John and Michael on an adventure to show them Never Land.

After hearing that Winnie has a brother, the lake boys decide that they should show Jake and Matt around town since they just moved to Nightland.

Peter Pan decides to take Wendy to go see Mermaid Lagoon, because that is something she has always wanted to see.

Patrick takes Winnie to the swim team's pool because she has always wanted to be apart of the team. They call the team's pool the Lagoon, because they always say that every one can swim like a fish while they are in it.

While there, Peter and Wendy see Captain Hook who has captured Tiger Lilly, the daughter of the Indian chief.

While they are there, they see Hannah with one of their friends who has been missing for the past week. They go to Hannah and take the girl with them.

While Peter is saving Tiger Lily, the lost boys, Michael and John get captured by Indians on their adventure of Never Land.

While Patrick saves Taylor, Jake, Matt, and the Lake boys get arrested for J-walking throughout the city.

In a reward for returning Tiger Lily safely, Chief frees the boys and throws a party for Tiger Lily's return.

Because Patrick and Winnie returned Taylor safely, the police officer agreed to let the boys go free in return. The police officer also tells them that he is going to throw a party in celebration for Taylor's return.

Wendy sees Peter and Tiger Lily dance together, and she begins to feel jealous.

At the party, Winnie notices that Patrick is dancing with Taylor a lot and starts to feel jealous of Taylor and the attention she is getting.

In the meantime, Hook convinces Tinker Bell to reveal the location of Peter and the boys by using her jealousy of Wendy against her.

Back at Hannah's house, Hannah convinces Patrick's best friend Tiffani to tell her where Patrick, Winnie, and the boys are staying.

In their home, Wendy realizes that she is ready to go back home, and the Lost Boys don't understand why. Wendy then sings to them a lullaby about what it's like to have a mother.

In Winnie's dorm they are all talking about their days when Winnie decides that she thinks she wants to live off campus in an apartment. This is also when Winnie explains to the boys what its like to live on your own.